You should log in:
  Forgot password?
Thingist is currently invitation-only.

Ryan's lists:

• $livelaugh puzzle playlist
• 2011/2012 Playlist
• 30 day projects
• Ads I like
• Adventures in design
• Adventures in Nerdery
• ah yes, Tempe
• April Foolery 2011
• Articles that I like
• as soon as I get off of work
• Assholes
• Autocad commands
• Awwwwww yeaaahhhhhh
• Badasses
• Beers I like
• Before I die
• Bicycle Saturday
• Billionaires with Facial Hair
• Blog
• Blog posts you should read
• Bonnaroo ideas
• Bookmarks
• Books I really really urgently need to read.
• Books to read
• breaking news
• Burning Man First Aid Kit
• Burning man packing list
• Burning Man Pictures
• Burning man road trip playlist
• Challenge a day
• Check ins
• color run photos
• Comics I love
• Cool ancient stuff
• Dear Alien Overlords
• Documentaries
• Dogfood
• Drawings and such
• Dream Garage
• Drinks I like
• Electro House
• electronics parts suppliers
• everything went better than expected
• Existence!
• Feels good, man
• Future Projects
• Gifs that should always be in the hopper
• Gifts for Geeks
• Gig stuff
• Gives me hope for the future of humanity
• Good bars in Phoenix
• Good food in Phoenix
• good things about being sick
• Great songs for coding
• Hacker Fuel
• Hacker Lore
• Hackerspace closing music
• Happy things
• hashtag lifehacks
• Heatsync Music
• Heros of mine
• How I know it's a bubble
• How I know it's the future already
• How things should be
• How to identify a hipster
• How to identify freshmen on a college campus
• Human bug tracker
• Humor
• I have amazing friends
• I love you, google
• Iced Dev Subsidiaries
• If Only
• India packing list
• Inspiration things
• Jay-Z lines
• lanmarks
• lectures
• lectures and talks I like
• Life lessons I wish I wasn't learning
• List of demands
• lol
• Magazines
• Make Log
• man, WHYYY!?!?
• Mashups I like
• me circa 2004 according to gmail
• Memetic Sillines
• Mix CD
• Montage Music
• Movies
• Movies I like
• Movies to watch with $alyson
• Music
• Music for $cody
• Music Sunday
• N64 Games to play
• Nostalgia
• OmNomNomNom
• Operation New Bicycle
• Parts I want
• People have too much money
• People I hope to meet someday
• People I like
• People who accidentally posted to Ryan's list.
• people you should check out
• Phoenix Repeaters I like
• Photo Of The Day
• Photo Things
• Photography Things
• Picnic Music Exchange
• Pictures of the dog
• places I want to visit
• Places that need faster wifi
• Places to go with $livelaugh this summer
• Please cure my sickness
• Programing Things
• Programming Milestones
• Proof that I actually leave the computer sometimes
• Quotes
• Rainy Day Music
• Reasons I love Google
• Reasons I love living in Arizona
• Reasons that $cody should go to burning man
• Reasons to move to Portland
• Reasons to move to San Francisco
• Recipes
• Relaxing Music
• Saguaro Man
• Second Saturday Sad Songs
• Someday
• Songs I like
• sounds a lot easier than it is
• Status
• Stuff for Dallas Office
• Stuff for saguaro man
• Stuff I'm working on
• Summer Songs
• Tech News
• thingist features
• Thingist todo list
• Things $alyson and Joe Rogan agree on
• Things $alyson says
• Things about bicycles
• Things for burning man
• Things for geeks
• Things for makers
• Things google+ got right
• Things google+ got wrong
• Things hipsters love
• Things I can't wait for
• Things I dislike about my house
• Things I hate
• Things I learned today
• Things I like
• Things I like in Oregon
• Things I love
• Things I read
• things I really did not think I would still be using in 2010
• Things I want for Christmas
• Things I want to play in.
• Things I want to teach $natalie
• Things I was wrong about
• Things I will do more of during unemployment
• Things I would recommend
• Things in my dream house
• Things Mitt Romney actually believes
• Things my crazy neighbor says
• Things my insane neighbor says
• Things on my bookshelf
• Things on the menu at a nerd-themed restaurant
• Things redditors like
• Things that $Natalie should teach me
• Things that Amy is amazingly good at
• Things that are real in my head, damnit!
• Things that can dance better than me
• Things that fly
• Things that give me hope for the future of humanity
• Things that made my day
• Things that make me fear for the future of humanity
• Things That Make Me Feel Better When I'm Sad
• Things that make me sad :(
• Things that might kill me
• Things that scare me
• Things that startupgrrl should do.
• Things to help you learn python
• Things Travis Says
• Things you should find in every IT department
• things you should read
• Things you should watch
• Thinngs I use my pocketknife for
• This is why
• times when cold weather is good
• Today in Hackery
• TV Shows I like
• US News
• useful windows things
• Wapred tour 2011 photos
• Warped Tour 2011 Photos
• we are doomed
• We basically live in Star Trek
• We're trying to have a society over here
• What is this demonry?
• What to do when life gives you lemons
• Why we can't have nice things
• Wine
• Words that are sexy
• Wub Wubs and Yip Yips
• Yes, I'm bragging
• you chose...poorly
• You dun goofed
• you're doing it right
• you're doing it wrong.
• You's trollin'
• Your move, government.
White until proven black - Race in The Hunger Games
Added to: Articles that I like
$natalie -- tagging you here because I didn't think that facebook was a good place to have the discussion :).

<Devil's advocate>

I don't think that this should be *that* shocking. It's just white kids who have only ever experienced being white assigning what they consider "normal" to characters that they encounter.

For instance, if I start telling a story, almost always, I'm telling the story from the standpoint of a white boy. To me, "white, male, lives in the US" is the default state because that's what I have been experiencing non stop for 25 years. Unless an author is fairly specific in outlining that a character *doesn't* fit this, that's what I generally assume is the case.

I think that people's *reaction* to finding out that this character didn't look like them is...really sad :(, but I don't necessarily think that their assumption that the character would be white should be that shocking.

A big part of me really hopes that these are just kids saying these things, and that they don't fully understand how horrible what they're implying is (although reading the blog, some of them sound like they're trying to be directly offensive).

Finding out that the character wasn't what you expected should have been a couple of seconds of "oh, huh?"

This has been something that I've talked about at length before, but it's relevant to this (and all discussions on cultural/sexual discrimination).

This idea that you're not "normal" is so hurtful on such a low level because it's so permanent.

"You will *never* be a part of the club"


"I will *never* accept you as $something".

The "never" part is what hurts so much.


/This/ to me is why discrimination hurts so much. It's this idea that no matter how good you are, no matter how hard you work, no matter if you're perfect in every single way, you're still, always, going to be an outsider.

That's really powerful, because your race, or your sex, are things that you can't change. The discrimination is saying that you are and forever shall be not-good-enough.


So to bring it back to the point here: people assuming the character was white is a reading comprehension problem, and a total non-issue. Finding out the character wasn't white should make the viewers "oops" over missing some details, but that's it.

When they get *upset* about this is when it becomes horrible.

| Share This

Please log in to use comment. (Registration is currently invite-only)